05 August 2007

尋日睇一套叫「小麥子」的福音記錄片(有興趣自己睇,我唔想簡介內容),當然,在那種場合(團契),實在是不適合我發表意見。所以唯有記之於blog,公諸於世,大家下次幾時「有幸」睇到o個套片,不妨諗諗以下呢幾句話,然後先再感謝神:

片中各人和席間各團友的看法,我想先用Bertrand Russell的"The Argument From Design"其中一句來回應:

"it is argued that rabbits have white tails in order to be easy to shoot. I do not know how rabbits would view that application."


竟然今時今日仲會有人話呢個小朋友患癌係by god's will,感動別人,傳揚宗教云云。呢種意見,同上面既argument一樣荒謬,所以同樣地,I do not know how the boy would view that application.

如果 "rabbits have white tails"既目的係"be easy to shoot",咁佢既white tails既存在,對兔仔而言只有係一齣悲劇,你會唔會叫佢因為咁而酬謝神恩﹖如果唔會,就唔該唔好將一個患病既小朋友同神拉上關係。正如希特拉屠殺六百萬猶太人之後,國際社會為左保護佢地,幫助佢地復國,咁我可唔可以話,希特拉大屠殺係神既旨意﹖你有種走去以色列咁講,你估下自己會係點死法﹖

閣下要傳教,不如就幫自己打支愛滋針然後傳到你自己滿意為止,唔好搵個細路o來較非。

No comments:

Post a Comment